This is one of those covers that I feel would be better in person than a digital file. I don't love it, but I think if it was in my hands I would feel different about it.
Why I Wanted to Read This:
I was asked to participate in the blog tour for Witherwood and Obert Skye is a popular middle school author so I decided to join up! Here's the synopsis from GoodReads:
Romance?: Not that kind of book!
This story started out laugh out loud funny. The first chapter when Tobias and Charlotte played their prank on their "nanny" was at times both funny and sad. For a dad who seemed to love his children as much as theirs did, he was certainly clueless when it came to his children's needs and who was watching them. But the description of the prank was gross and funny. It would make a good read aloud.
I loved the author's style of writing. I am not sure that authors like being compared to Roald Dahl, but that is was kept coming to mind as I got started reading this. Fortunately kids really don't get tired or reading the wacky and unbelievable if there is a good dose of humor with it. I haven't read any other Obert Skye books but was pleased at this style of writing. And a boarding school is always a good setting for the fantastic to happen.
I liked Tobias and Charlotte, very relate able characters. Tobias dives right in without thinking ahead and Charlotte observes more, but goes along with Tobias. They are fiercely loyal to each other and when they find themselves at Witherwood they are worried, scared and lonely. Kind of like kids starting middle school for the first time!
Witherwood is a great setting, perhaps evil, certainly not normal and a little scary. I loved the illustrations and glad they were included. This book could get away without the, because of the authors clear descriptions, but I felt they added to the reading for me.
This is a series, so intends with no real resolution, which I didn't love. It's a reason I never read the whole Series of Unfortunate Events. I like a little more of an uptick at the end of my books, even ones that are series. However, it never seems to bother young readers. This one will fit comfortably on my middle school library shelf, but not for long because I think it will be very popular.
To Sum Up: I think this would be a great beginning of the school year read aloud, but also just a fun read for older elementary and younger middle school readers.
Macmillan is offering a copy of Witherwood Reform School to one of my readers. Please fill out the form below to enter to win. US residents only, contest runs through March 15.
Please visit the other blogs involved in this tour:
2/18: Little Red Reads
2/19: A Reader’s Adventure
2/20: Stories & Sweeties
2/23: The Hiding Spot
2/24: Bumbles and Fairytales
2/25: Manga Maniac Café
2/26: The Book Monsters
2/27: Mundie Kids
3/2: Milk & Cookies: Comfort Reading
3/3: Green Bean Teen Queen